Tesla Model Y vs Volkswagen ID.4

Compare range, price, 0-60 mph, charging speed, and full specs side by side.

By ·

Compare EVs Side by Side

Select 2-3 electric vehicles to compare range, price, performance, and specs.

Vehicle 1
Vehicle 2
↔️

Select at least 2 vehicles to start comparing.
▸ THE NUMBERS COMPETITORS DON'T SHOW

Resale, warranty & insurance — side by side

Edmunds and KBB compare specs. We compare the three things that actually move dollars over the ownership cycle.

2-Year Resale Retention
Tesla Model Y
84% 2024 model · $37,800 avg used · A
Volkswagen ID.4
77.5% 2024 model · $30,800 avg used · B+
Tesla Model Y holds value better by 6.5 percentage points at 2 years.
See full depreciation rankings →
Battery Warranty
Tesla Model Y
8 yr / 120,000 mi 70% SOH floor · transferable
Volkswagen ID.4
8 yr / 100,000 mi 70% SOH floor · transferable
Tesla Model Y has the better battery warranty.
See every EV warranty ranked →
Annual Insurance (US Avg)
Tesla Model Y
$2,900/yr Vermont: $1,500 · Michigan: $6,200
Volkswagen ID.4
$2,400/yr Hawaii: $1,111 · Michigan: $4,808
Volkswagen ID.4 is cheaper to insure by $500/yr on average.
Run your state-specific quote →

Tesla Model Y vs Volkswagen ID.4: Which EV Should You Buy?

Choosing between the Tesla Model Y and Volkswagen ID.4? Use the interactive comparison above to see how they stack up on range, price, performance, and charging speed. Whether you searched "Tesla Model Y vs Volkswagen ID.4" or "Volkswagen ID.4 vs Tesla Model Y" — same comparison, picked apart trim-by-trim. Select different trims to compare specific configurations.

Quick reference: this page covers the head-to-head between the Tesla Model Y and the Volkswagen ID.4 (the reverse "Volkswagen ID.4 vs Tesla Model Y" matchup is the same comparison from the opposite vehicle's perspective). Both directions land here.

View Tesla Model Y Details → View Volkswagen ID.4 Details →